The National Laws and Regulatory Landscape for Autonomous Vehicles in UK and Germany
Introduction
The development and deployment of autonomous vehicles on public roads have presented significant regulatory challenges across Europe. UK and Germany, as major automotive and technological hubs, are working to create frameworks that balance innovation with safety and public acceptance. These countries and the EU have been actively engaged in formulating and adapting their legal frameworks to accommodate this emerging technology.
Taxonomy for Autonomous Vehicles
Autonomous vehicles (AV), as defined by the Society of Automotive Engineers (SAE), are vehicles capable of performing all driving functions under certain conditions without human intervention. In 2021, it refines and clarifies the concept of failure mitigation strategy and the differences between Level 3 and Level 4 in SAE J3016 recommended practice. In Level 4, the vehicles can drive themselves safely in specific operational design domains (ODDs), which may include geographic areas, roadway types, speed ranges, and environmental conditions. They are capable of performing all driving tasks within a defined ODD without human intervention. However, they may not be able to handle all possible driving scenarios and may require human takeover in certain situations outside the ODD. This level of autonomy represents a significant step forward from traditional human-driven vehicles and demands a comprehensive regulatory approach.
UK Regulatory Landscape
In the UK, the regulatory environment for autonomous vehicles is evolving. The government has been actively promoting research and development in this area. The Automated and Electric Vehicles Act 2018 is a key piece of legislation. It addresses liability issues, stating that the insurer of an autonomous vehicle will be liable in the event of an accident, provided the vehicle was operating within its automated mode at the time of the incident. This provides clarity and protection for consumers and encourages the adoption of autonomous vehicle technology.
The UK also has initiatives such as the Centre for Connected and Autonomous Vehicles (CCAV), which works on testing and trialling autonomous vehicles. The country has been conducting various pilot projects in different cities and regions to gather data and understand the real-world implications of Level 4 AVs. For example, in Milton Keynes, a trial of autonomous pods has been underway, testing their operation in urban environments and interaction with pedestrians and other vehicles.
Post-Brexit, the UK has the opportunity to develop its own independent regulatory path. In May 2024, the groundbreaking Automated Vehicles (AV) Act became law, paving the way for self-driving cars to be on British roads by 2026. This landmark legislation sets the regulatory framework for the safe deployment of Level 4 AVs, addressing key issues such as liability, insurance, and safety standards. It can potentially be more agile in adapting regulations to the rapid pace of technological change, but it also needs to ensure that its standards remain compatible with international norms to avoid trade barriers and ensure the safety and acceptance of its autonomous vehicle exports.
Germany's Approach to Regulation
Germany, with its strong automotive manufacturing base, has a meticulous approach to regulating autonomous vehicles. The German Road Traffic Act (Straßenverkehrsgesetz (StVG)) has been amended to account for autonomous driving. It stipulates that the human driver must be able to take over control of the vehicle when prompted by the autonomous system, even if the vehicle is operating in an autonomous mode. This ensures a certain level of human oversight and responsibility.
Germany has also been involved in several research and development projects, such as the PEGASUS project. This project focuses on developing safety concepts and ethical guidelines for autonomous vehicles. The German government and industry partners are collaborating to define the acceptable risks and behaviours of autonomous vehicles within different driving scenarios. Moreover, German manufacturers like Mercedes-Benz and BMW are actively testing their Level 4 autonomous vehicle prototypes on public roads in Germany, subject to strict regulatory compliance. The country is also working on standards for vehicle-to-vehicle (V2V) and vehicle-to-infrastructure (V2I) communication, which are essential for the seamless operation of autonomous vehicles in a connected environment.
EU Regulatory
The EU has been playing a significant role in shaping the regulatory landscape for autonomous vehicles. The General Safety Regulation (GSR) and the Automated Lane Keeping Systems (ALKS) Regulation are two important directives. The GSR sets out a wide range of safety requirements for all motor vehicles, including those with autonomous features. It focuses on areas such as advanced driver assistance systems (ADAS) and cyber security. The ALKS Regulation specifically addresses the use of automated lane keeping systems, which is a precursor to more advanced levels of autonomy. It defines the conditions under which such systems can be used and the safety measures that must be in place.
The EU is also working on a framework for type approval of AVs. This will ensure that vehicles meet common safety and performance standards across all member states. The European Commission is collaborating with national authorities and industry stakeholders to develop these regulations in a way that balances innovation and safety. However, the process is complex due to the need to consider the diverse interests and capabilities of different member states.
At the EU level, the proposed AI Act aims to establish harmonised rules for the development and use of AI systems, including those employed in autonomous vehicles. The Act outlines stringent requirements for high-risk AI systems, such as those used in AVs, to ensure they are safe, transparent, and respect fundamental rights, including data privacy.
Data Protection and Cybersecurity
Data protection is a major concern for autonomous vehicles. These vehicles collect and transmit vast amounts of data, including information about the vehicle's surroundings, the driving behavior of other vehicles, and the personal data of passengers. In the EU, the General Data Protection Regulation (GDPR) applies, which requires companies to obtain proper consent for data collection and to ensure the security and privacy of the data. In these two countries, additional measures are being considered to address the specific data protection challenges of autonomous vehicles. Cybersecurity is also a top priority. Autonomous vehicles are vulnerable to hacking and other cyber threats, which could potentially lead to loss of control or the theft of sensitive data. National and EU regulations are being developed to require manufacturers to implement robust cybersecurity measures, such as encryption, intrusion detection systems, and regular software updates.
Testing and Certification Requirements
Testing and certification of Level 3-4-5 autonomous vehicles are essential to ensure their safety and compliance. In UK and Germany, there are specific procedures for testing autonomous vehicles on public roads. These usually involve obtaining permits, demonstrating compliance with safety standards, and having a plan in place for handling emergencies. The EU is working on a unified testing and certification framework. This will involve standardised test procedures, performance metrics, and evaluation criteria. Manufacturers will need to demonstrate that their vehicles can operate safely within their defined ODDs and can handle various driving scenarios, including adverse weather conditions and unexpected events.
In the UK, the Pathway to Driverless Cars report outlines the framework for testing AVs on public roads. A test driver must be present and responsible for the safe operation of the vehicle during testing. Additionally, the vehicle must comply with existing road traffic laws and regulations.
Public Perception and Acceptance
The success of autonomous vehicles also depends on public perception and acceptance. In both countries, public awareness campaigns and education initiatives are being carried out. These aim to inform the public about the benefits and risks of autonomous driving, and to address concerns such as job losses in the transportation sector and the safety of sharing the road with autonomous vehicles. Surveys and studies are being conducted to understand public attitudes and to identify areas where further education and communication are needed. For example, in Germany, public consultations have been held to gather input on the ethical and legal aspects of autonomous driving.
In the UK, a survey conducted by the Society of Motor Manufacturers and Traders (SMMT) revealed a cautious yet optimistic stance. While 59% of respondents expressed concerns about vehicle safety, a significant portion (49%) believed that self-driving cars could improve road safety in the long run. In another survey from Volkswagen Financial Services UK, 39% of drivers expressed concerns about technological failings or mishaps, while over a quarter (27%) felt the technology would remove unsafe drivers from the roads. The results of the survey highlighted the importance of public education and trust-building measures to foster wider acceptance.
Conclusion
The regulation of AVs on public roads in the UK and Germany is a complex and evolving process. National laws and EU regulations are being developed and refined to balance innovation, safety, liability, cybersecurity, infrastructure readiness, and public acceptance. While each country has its own approach, the successful deployment of AVs will require a harmonised, cross-border approach within the EU. As the technology continues to advance, further adaptations and enhancements to the regulatory landscape will be necessary. Collaboration between governments, policymakers, car makers, technology companies, and the public will be crucial in navigating this complex landscape. The successful integration of autonomous vehicles into public roads will require the continued efforts to ensure a safe and seamless transition for these vehicles operating safely, ethically, and in a manner that benefits society as a whole.
Please share it with your network!
Back